FIDIC Rainbow Edition, 1999 updated: FIDIC Rainbow, 2nd Edition 2017 has been published
By Rechtsanwalt Dr. Götz-Sebastian Hök
In 2008, a significant landmark occurred in the development of the FIDIC contracts. This was the launch of the FIDIC Design, Build and Operate form of Contract—the FIDIC Gold Book. Major concepts and policies have been adopted by the new FIDIC Rainbow suite. However, still a contract form for brownfield scenarios is missing but in the FIDC pipeline (the future FIDIC “Bronze Book”).
At the annual FIDIC Users´ Conference at London in December 2016 FIDIC has published the Pre-Release of the FIDIC Yellow Book (Plant & Deisgn, Build), 2nd Edition. At that time it was planned to publish the full suite of new FIDIC forms of contract during the first half of 2017.
One year later, on the occasion of the next FIDIC IBC Users´ Conference at London 2017 the Fédération Internationale des Ingénieurs-Conseils (FIDIC) or International Federation of Consulting Engineers has finally launched as an update of the FIDIC 1999 Conditions of Contract for Construction (Red Book), First Edition FIDIC the 2nd Edition of the famous FIDIC Rainbow Edition including the second edition of the FIDIC Red Book, the 2nd Edition of the FIDIC Yellow Book, and the 2nd Edition of the FIDIC Silver Book.
Already in 2006 FIDIC had established Task Group 6 having been responsible for the review and updating of the FIDIC Rainbow suite of contracts, including the FIDIC Red Book for construction works, the FIDIC Yellow Book for Design and Build and the FIDIC Silver Book (EPC/T). However, it took until December 2017 to publish the 2nd Edition of this FIDIC Rainbow. Also the new Edition was written by engineers for engineers. As usual, consultations with major stakeholders were made before launching the new Edition. The traditional route - Contracts Committee sets out "terms of reference" - TG drafts a proposal in accordance with the "terms of reference" - friendly review - legal review and approval by Executive Committee. The review was made for each book separately and also a review of the dispute adjudication part was done separately and individually.
Reported experiences, advice and comments from the industry, funding institutions and insuring companies and other stakeholders have been taken in consideration. FIDIC emphasizes that user friendliness and fair risk allocation have been maintained.
The new FIDIC Rainbow continues FIDIC’s fundamental principles of balanced risk sharing referring to “best practice” while seeking to build on the substantial experience gained from its use over the past 18 years. For example, this edition provides:
greater detail and clarity on the requirements for notices and other communications resulting in a more formal approach;
verbal strengthening of the role of the Engineer
harmonized provisions in respect of Employers’ and Contractors’ claims which are in future treated equally and separated from disputes;
emphasis on dispute avoidance;
standing Dispute Avoidance / Dispute Adjudication Boards (DAABs) as a rule under all FIDIC forms of Contract;
revised wording on the enforcement of DAAB decisions, and
more detailed provisions for quality assurance, and verification of Contractor’s contractual compliance with quality requirements.
This –new- suite of Conditions of Contract includes general conditions, which are likely to apply to the majority of such contracts. Essential items of information which are particular to each individual contract are to be included in the Particular Conditions Part A – Contract Data replacing the former Appendix to Tender.
In addition, it is recognised that many Employers, especially governmental agencies, may require special conditions of contract, or particular procedures, which differ from those included in the General Conditions. These should be included in Part B – Special Provisions.
FIDIC notes, that the General Conditions and the Particular Conditions (Part A – Contract Data and Part B – Special Provisions) are all part of the Conditions of Contract.
To assist Employers in preparing tender documents and in drafting Particular Conditions of Contract for specific contracts, the new FIDIC books include
Notes on the Preparation of Tender Documents, and
Notes on the Preparation of Special Provisions, which provide important advice to drafters of contract documents, in particular the Specifications and Special Provisions.
In drafting Special Provisions, if clauses in the General Conditions are to be substituted, omitted or supplemented and before incorporating any example wording, Employers are urged to seek legal and engineering advice in an effort to avoid ambiguity and to ensure completeness and consistency with the other provisions of the contract and the project purpose.
FIDIC Task Group 15 is working on FIDIC Golden Principles which must be complied with in order to call a contract a FIDIC contract. This complementary guidance as included in the Guidance for the Preparation of Particular Conditions - Particular Conditions Part B – Special Provisions- Introduction should be carefully taken in account.
Each new FIDIC book begins with a series of comprehensive flow charts which typically show, in visual and comprehensive but not exhaustive form, the sequences of activities which characterise the FIDIC Construction form of contract. The charts are illustrative, however, and FIDIC advises users that they must not be taken into consideration in the interpretation of the Conditions of Contract.
The new series of books also includes a number of sample forms to help both Parties to develop a common understanding of what is required by third parties such as providers of securities and guarantees.
FIDIC reminds drafters of contract documents that the General Conditions of all FIDIC contracts are protected by copyright and trademark and may not be changed without specific written consent, usually in the form of a licence to amend, from FIDIC. If drafters wish to amend the provisions found in the General Conditions, the place for doing this is in the Particular Conditions Part B – Special Provisions, as mentioned above, and not by making changes in the General Conditions as published.
Moreover, FIDIC considers the official and authentic FIDIC texts to be the versions in the English language.
FIDIC considers the official and authentic texts to be the versions in the English language.
There is significant editorial change, like
Definitions now in an alphabetical order
Abbreviations used and defined [e.g. IPC, NOD, DNP, FPC, etc.]
Clauses subdivided in Sub-Sub-Clauses, e.g. S-C 3.7.1 …, 4.12, 20.1 etc.
Extension to 21 Clauses
Increased number of Sub-Clauses plus Sub-Sub-Clauses
Renaming of Clauses [e.g. FM = Exceptional Risks]
Former S-C 4.10 divided in S-C 2.5 [Site Data] and S-C 4.10 [Use of Site Data]
Restructuring of Clauses [Insurance now Clause 19, Employer´s Claims now Clause 20, Dispute Resolution now Clause 21]
Actually the new FIDIC forms include
In substance the new forms provide e.g.:
Much more definitions
Enhanced programming wording
Contractual machinery for claims and disputes
Interrelated dispute adjudication wording
It seems that the driving factor when updating the new Rainbow edition was to review and revise the claims´ and dispute concepts and the related wording.
In terms of concepts it is worth to mention that the Employers will in future be subjected to the same constraints and time bars regarding claims as Contractors. Both are treated equally and must give notices and particulars in time, give early warning notices and keep contemporary records.
However, the core element of the new series of contract is an integrated or interwoven claims´ and dispute machinery or claims´ pipeline. A claim which may be a Claim, as defined in the Conditions, or a matter to be determined by the Engineer under the Conditions, or otherwise, which has become a dispute will -as a principle- result in a DAAB decision unless the “claim” was agreed or settled otherwise. The flow and sequence of claim related activities (such as Notice, submission of particulars, consultation, determination, etc.) which are interwoven can be interrupted by inactivity of the claimant. Only an active claimant will be successful. An active claimant will have to supervise the claims´ procedure and must take action by giving a Notice of dissatisfaction even if the Engineer remains inactive and not only if when the Engineer acts to the dissatisfaction of the claimant. Dissatisfied claimants are under the duty to refer the matter to the DAAB without delay or better within given delays. Any delay of a claimant in respect of any claims´ related activity is likely to result in disadvantage and/or foreclosure.
The endeavour was to establish clear definitions in order to avoid debate and disputes. Notice giving in minutes of meeting and/or orally was spotted as source of disputes. Inactivity by the Engineer had been identified to be annoying and causing disputes from time to time. The FIDIC answers are:
Notices must be given as a written communication identified as a Notice and issued in accordance with Sub-Clause 1.3 – a more formal and therefore more clear approach
Inactivity of the Engineer in respect of claims results in as if the relevant Engineer´s action was undertaken to the disadvantage of the claimant, meaning a claim may be deemed to be either foreclosed or rejected
Users who intend to establish a supply chain are well advised to continue using the FIDIC 1999 Edition in that the existing FIDIC subcontract as published in 2011 is not fit for use with the FIDIC Rainbow Edition 2017. Also the work on the design and build subcontract will be based on FIDIC 1999. Thus, it is not likely to happen soon that a new subcontract will be available which would be fit with the new series of contract.
The FIDIC White Book, 5th Edition 2017 can be used to hire the Engineer to act as the Engineer under the new FIDIC Red Book or Yellow Book, 2017 Edition.
LAW OFFICE Dr. Hök, Stieglmeier & Kollegen
Contact: Advocate Dr.Götz-Sebastian Hök
Eschenallee 22, 14050 Berlin
Tel.: 00 49 (0) 30 3000 760-0
Fax: 00 49 (0) 30 3000 760 33
WARNING: the material contained in these notes is a simplified guide to some of the major topics in international and German construction law. It is not intended as a substitute for legal advice on individual transactions, and does not necessarily stand on its own. Whilst the contents are believed to be correct, the authors cannot accept any responsibility for errors or omissions.